Al Noor LanguagesEnglish tests and languages
IELTS Academic

Task 2 at Band 6, 7 and 8: one question, three answers

The same essay written three times, with what each criterion rewards and exactly what moves an answer up a band.

22 minutes · A free lesson from Writing: the band ladder

Most advice about Band 7 is abstract: "develop your ideas", "use a range of vocabulary". This lesson shows it instead. Below is one Task 2 question answered three times, at about Band 6, Band 7 and Band 8, with notes on each of the four criteria the examiner uses: Task Response, Coherence and Cohesion, Lexical Resource, and Grammatical Range and Accuracy.

Read the question first and decide what you would argue. Then read the three answers in order.

The question

Some people think that mobile phones should be banned in schools completely. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

About Band 6

Nowadays, mobile phones are very common among students and many schools have problem with them. Some people think that phones should be banned in schools completely. I agree with this opinion for some reasons.

Firstly, mobile phones distract students in the class. When a student receive a message, he will want to check it immediately and he will not listen to the teacher. For example, my cousin is always checking his phone in the class and his marks became lower last year. Also, many students play games or use social media in the break time instead of talking with their friends. This is very bad for their social skills.

Secondly, phones can cause problems like cyberbullying. Students can take photos of other students and share them on the internet without permission. This can make some students very upset and they don't want to come to school. Teachers cannot control this easily because it happen outside the classroom.

On the other hand, some people say that phones are useful in emergency. For example, if a child is sick, the parents can call him. However, schools have telephones in the office, so parents can call the school. Moreover, students can use phones for learning, for example to search information. But schools have computers for this, so it is not necessary.

In conclusion, I believe that the advantages of banning phones are more than the disadvantages. Schools should ban phones completely so students can focus on their study and have better relationships with their classmates.

252 words. A clear answer with a position, held back by under-developed ideas, mechanical linking and repeated small errors.

Why about Band 6

About Band 7

Mobile phones have become a normal part of children's lives, and schools are increasingly divided over whether to allow them. In my view, a complete ban during lessons is justified, although I do not think phones need to be banned from school premises altogether.

The strongest argument for restricting phones is that they make it harder for students to concentrate. Even when a phone is switched to silent, the knowledge that a message might be waiting can pull a student's attention away from the lesson. Teachers also lose time dealing with students who use their phones secretly, which affects the whole class rather than just one individual. Removing phones from the classroom therefore benefits everyone, including those who would never misuse them.

However, a total ban, from the moment students arrive until they leave, seems unnecessarily strict. Many parents want their children to be able to contact them on the way to and from school, particularly if they travel alone or by public transport. In addition, older students sometimes use phones to check timetables, submit assignments or photograph notes, and these are reasonable uses that schools should not ignore.

A more practical solution is to require students to hand in their phones, or keep them locked away, during lessons, while allowing them at the beginning and end of the day. This approach protects learning time without preventing families from staying in touch.

In conclusion, I agree that phones should not be used in lessons, but I believe that a complete ban goes too far. Clear rules about when phones may be used would achieve the same goal more fairly.

269 words. A position with a condition, ideas that are explained and supported, and natural linking.

What moved it up to about Band 7

About Band 8

Few issues divide parents and teachers as sharply as the place of smartphones in school. I agree that phones should be kept out of lessons entirely, but a ban that extends to every minute of the school day would, in my view, create almost as many problems as it solves.

The case for removing phones from classrooms is compelling. Concentration is fragile, and a device designed to compete for attention does not stop competing simply because it is on silent: the mere possibility of a notification is enough to break a teenager's focus. The cost is not only individual, either. Every minute a teacher spends confiscating a phone, or dealing with an argument that began on social media, is a minute taken from the rest of the class. Seen in this light, keeping phones out of lessons is less a punishment than a way of protecting the time that school exists to provide.

Extending the ban to breaks, journeys and the hours before and after lessons is a different matter. For a child who crosses a city alone, a phone is a practical safeguard, and many parents would understandably be reluctant to give that up. A blanket ban also misses an opportunity: learning to put a phone away when it is not needed is itself a skill, and one that schools are well placed to teach.

The most sensible policy, therefore, is a clear boundary rather than total prohibition, with phones handed in at the start of each lesson and returned once it ends. Such a rule removes the distraction where it matters most, while respecting the legitimate reasons families have for wanting their children to be reachable.

In short, the classroom should be phone-free, but the school day need not be.

292 words. Every idea fully extended, a precise argument from start to finish, and language that is wide-ranging and controlled.

What moved it up to about Band 8

Lesson quiz

Check what you have learned. Choose an answer to see whether it is right, and why.

Quick check: What is the biggest difference between the Band 6 and Band 7 essays?

  1. The Band 7 essay is much longer
  2. The Band 7 essay uses more linking words
  3. The Band 7 essay develops each idea instead of listing them
Show the answer

C: The Band 7 essay develops each idea instead of listing them — Explain, give an example, show the result: one developed idea beats three listed ones.

Quick check: Which of these is typical of the Band 6 essay?

  1. A linking word at the start of almost every paragraph
  2. A position that changes halfway through
  3. No conclusion
Show the answer

A: A linking word at the start of almost every paragraph — Firstly, Secondly, Moreover, However: correct but mechanical.

Quick check: What makes the Band 8 vocabulary strong?

  1. It uses as many rare words as possible
  2. Each word is precise and natural in its context
  3. It avoids all common words
Show the answer

B: Each word is precise and natural in its context — Compelling, fragile, a blanket ban: chosen to fit, not to impress.

Quick check: How exact are the bands given to these essays?

  1. They are official IELTS scores
  2. They are guaranteed for any similar essay
  3. They are estimates, and an examiner might differ by half a band
Show the answer

C: They are estimates, and an examiner might differ by half a band — They show the difference between levels, not a score you can rely on.

Write your own: will online courses replace classrooms?
Marked as soon as you finish — free with an account.
Practise now

Practise what you just learnt

Create a free Al Noor account to do the marked practice for this lesson, track your progress through IELTS Academic, and take the free diagnostic test.